Please check out the new WECF website on!

Stay here to browse our website archive (2004-2019).

WECF Deutschland

WECF France

WECF Nederland




European Chemicals Agency sued for withholding names of toxics producers

The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) is being sued over its refusal to release the names of companies producing some of the most dangerous chemicals in the EU market

09.05.2011 |ChemSec & ClientEarth Press Release

The lawsuit, brought by environmental law organisation ClientEarth and chemicals watchdog ChemSec, alleges several violations of European laws designed to promote transparency, democracy, and legitimacy in EU policy-making.
The chemicals are 356 of those on the SIN (Substitute it Now!) list, developed by ChemSec in collaboration with other NGOs. The listcomprises chemicals identified as Substances of Very High Concern under the EU chemicals regulation REACH. These are chemicals that can cause cancer, damage our reproductive system, or alter our DNA, as well as toxic substances that accumulate in nature with serious and long-term irreversible effects.[1]
ECHA has refused to disclose both the names of the facilities producing these dangerous chemicals and the amounts in which they are placed in the EU market. ClientEarth and ChemSec state that this refusal conflicts REACH, designed to protect public health by prohibiting the unsafe use of chemicals, as well as EU transparency laws on disclosure of environmental information.
Vito Buonsante, toxics lawyer at ClientEarth, says: “The public’s right to information on chemicals is a basic principle of the REACH Regulation. ECHA must not be allowed to withhold information on such a critical issue, especially as it relates to chemicals found in consumer products and present in the EU in large quantities. We have exhausted all avenues to make ECHA meet its transparency obligations and are now compelled to go to court.”
Jerker Ligthart, ChemSec’s SIN List project coordinator, says: “ClientEarth and ChemSec are fighting to establish a principle: that people have the right to know about dangerous chemicals to which they and their environment are exposed. These chemicals are present in many consumer products, from detergents and paints to computers and toys, and often in high concentrations. Knowing who is producing dangerous substances, and the level of exposure, is vital to safeguard the public. Commercial interests should not be given precedence over people’s health.”
ECHA has a track record of being slow to disclose information about chemicals; pressure from the chemicals industry has so far been successful in making delays characteristic of the Agency’s approach, despite this policy’s clear contravention of REACH and EU principles established for almost 20 years. ClientEarth and ChemSec intend that their case will make the agency afford public health protection the precedence and immediacy it deserves.

For further details of ClientEarth and ChemSec’s case and the substances concerned, please click here
Mike Haines | ClientEarth | t. +44 (0) 207 749 5978 | m. +44 (0) 7841 918 770 | e.
Jerker Ligthart | ChemSec  | t. +46 31 711 01 52 e.

ClientEarth is an environmental law organisation working in the public interest. Based in Europe and operating globally, we address issues including deforestation, energy efficiency, biodiversity protection, and the transparency and enforcement of environmental

ChemSec, the International Chemical Secretariat, is a non-profit organisation working for a toxic free world by highlighting the health and environmental risks of hazardous substances, make accurate, science-based information readily available, engage business and speed up legislative processes.

Related News

Getting to the Future We Want
4-7 November, Brussels: European Environmental Bureau’s (EEB) Annual Conference

Human Biomonitoring for Europe
Vienna, 26 September: stakeholder forum

A life without plastic, wouldn't it be fantastic?!
Interview with Charlotte Schueler of @PlastikfreiLeben, who lives a zerowaste life in Munich, Germany and shares her experiences to her 25.2 thousand followers on instagram & 37.2 thousand followers on facebook

Calling for periods free from plastic & hazardous chemicals
Letter to Frédérique Ries, MEP, European Parliament on behalf of the #BreakFreeFromPlastics movement